English | 中文
Reporting FOCAC
  • Home
  • China-Africa 101
    • 5 China-Africa Myths >
      • Myth #1: Chinese Workers
      • Myth #2: Chinese FDI
      • Myth #3: Prison Labor
      • Myth #4: Trade
      • Myth #5: Central Planning
    • 10 Things You Need To Know
    • Chinese Media in Africa
    • Chinese Aid to Africa
  • Reporter Resources
    • Reporting on China-Africa
    • Covering FOCAC
    • VIDEO: FOCAC EXPERT ANALYSIS
  • Online Resources
    • The China-Africa Twitter List
    • Useful China-Africa Sites
    • China-Africa Long Reads
    • 5 Must-Read China-Africa Books
    • 5 Must-See China-Africa Docs
  • About Us
    • The China Africa Project
    • Wits China-Africa Reporting Project

5 myths about the chinese in africa

Click to enlarge (PDF)
Picture

Don't get fooled!

Myths, stereotypes and even outright lies about the Chinese in Africa are remarkably durable. Too much reporting on China's engagement on the continent is oversimplified and relies on unverified anecdotes.

When covering the China-Africa relationship, many reporters inadvertently come with existing narratives they then seek to reaffirm in their coverage. This explains why many myths about the Chinese in Africa are recycled over and over again - despite a lack of evidence.

The China-Africa relationship also covers a lot of ground. Is the China-Africa story economic? Political? Military? Cultural? Environmental? It's all of this and more. For many journalists who lack the necessary background it can feel overwhelming, and often leads to an oversimplification of the story to make it digestible for themselves and their audiences.

This is not a simple story to cover. Therefore, it is essential to avoid journalistic shortcuts that rely on unsubstantiated information about the way China and Africa interact.

Picture

Myth #1: Chinese companies in Africa only hire Chinese workers

The presence of Chinese labor in Africa is both controversial and poorly understood. Although PRC companies import a significant number of workers, the facts disprove the myth that the majority of workers on Chinese-funded projects are Chinese.

Myth #2: China is africa's #1 investor

Although China is by far Africa's largest trading partner, the size of its investment portfolio on the continent is relatively small. Many journalists inaccurately conflate TRADE with INVESTMENT. By 2015, China ranked only #7 in African foreign direct investment, far behind the United States, Germany, and even the United Arab Emirates.
Picture

Picture

Myth #3: china exports prison labor to work in africa

For years researchers have scoured Africa for evidence that China exports prisoners to Africa. To date, they have found no such evidence. Absolutely none. While people share fantastic stories based on hearing about Chinese prison camps, guards and convicts, these are almost certainly myths based on misunderstandings.

Myth #4: africa is now one of china's top trading partners

While China is now one of Africa's most important trading partners, the reverse is not true. Africa represents less than 5% of China's global trade balance, most of it in commodities that can be sourced elsewhere. Africa barely registers in terms of the value of its trade compared to the PRC's major trading partners in Europe, the USA and the Middle East.
Picture

Picture

myth #5: chinese investments in africa are centrally planned in beijing

China is a Communist government and the Chinese domestic economy is sometimes still centrally planned. In the past this included encouraging Chinese companies to expand abroad. However, the decision of where to go is made by the companies alone and almost always guided by a single factor: profits.
This site is a collaboration between The China Africa Project and The Wits China-Africa Reporting Project at Wits University in Johannesburg, South Africa. None of the blog’s authors or producers have any vested interest in a particular policy or position, Chinese, African, Western or otherwise. Copyright 2015 The China Africa Project and The Wits China-Africa Reporting Project. All Rights Reserved.
本网站是中非项目和金山大学中非报道项目的一项合作。对于提到的政策和立场,所有的博客作者或制作人都均不涉及个人利益。2015‭ ‬中非项目版权所有违者必究.

Picture
Picture
✕